"Don't Settle For Me" is the second reprise of the song "Settle For Me" this time sung by Heather Davis to Greg Serrano (who also takes part in the song). Heather realized her boyfriend at the time was in love with Rebecca Bunch and confronted Greg with the truth in song. She also broke up with him refusing to be his second choice. Heather encouraged Greg to confess his feelings to the true object of his affections. This second reprise was first heard in the Season One episode "Josh and I Go to Los Angeles!".
The song with lyrics
- This is essentially the second reprise of the song "Settle For Me"; the original song was performed by Greg accompanied by Rebecca, the first reprise (or "Settle For Him") was done with Rebecca by herself. Both of those versions were in the episode "I'm Going on a Date with Josh's Friend!". Unlike the previous ones, the third song is a more stripped down version featuring only an acoustic guitar to accompany the vocals.
- In the following episode "Josh is Going to Hawaii!", Heather admits to Greg that this song was a test to see if he was truly invested in thier relationship. He failed the test when he chose to go see Rebecca and broke Heather's heart in the process.