- "I Hope Josh Comes to My Party!": The Giant fish is shown in the corner of Rebecca's apartment inside a box . It's later revealed by Heather that during the party at Rebecca's place a drunk Greg Serrano slow danced with the fish.
- "I'm Going on a Date with Josh's Friend!": The giant fish is seen outside of the box leaning against the wall in the background of Rebecca's apartment.
- "I'm So Happy That Josh Is So Happy!": When Rebecca takes an ADD pill she found at Dr. Noelle Akopian's restroom she temporarily hangs the giant fish up and decorates it with Christmas lights.
- "That Text Was Not Meant for Josh!": Greg notices the new decor in Rebecca's apartment and points out the giant fish has been properly mounted on the wall.
- "Josh and I Go to Los Angeles!": The giant fish is seen in the background when Trent welcomes Rebecca home for dinner.
- "Josh Has No Idea Where I Am!": When Rebecca goes missing Greg tells Darryl, Paula and Josh he calls dibs on the giant fish if she doesn't return.
- "Josh's Sister is Getting Married!": The fish appears in the background when Rebecca trashes all her Josh related inventory.
- "Why Is Josh in a Bad Mood?": The fish appears in the background during Greg's performance of "I Gave You a UTI".
- "Who Needs Josh When You Have a Girl Group?": The giant fish is one of several items Rebecca moved into her new home.