Settle For Her

“Settle For Her [Cut Song]”
Performer(s): Nathaniel Plimpton III — First Appearance: "Crazy Ex-Girlfriend: Original Television Soundtrack (Season 3)"
Written by: Adam Schlesinger, Rachel Bloom

Settle for her. Come on just settle for her. The smart, hot, sweet and mature girl who doesn’t break the law!

— Nathaniel Plimpton III, "Trent?!"

“Settle For Her” (officially “Settle For Her [Cut Song]”) was an unused musical performance by Scott Michael Foster (as Nathaniel Plimpton III). This was intended to be the third reprise of the Season One song “Settle For Me.” A leitmotif of the song was used in its place. This song was later released as track 37 on the official Crazy Ex-Girlfriend: Original Television Soundtrack (Season 3) album.

The song with lyrics

Lyrics: Settle for her. Come on just settle for her. The smart, hot, sweet and mature girl who doesn’t break the law! Why do I feel she’s second place in this game? It’s easy to see she’s perfect for me, plus she’s not insane. So it’s not settling for her If she and I someday were To say ‘I do’ and have some kids and be content! But why do I feel that I want more? Settling down is not settling for... I’m on solid ground yet I’m reeling... what’s unsettling is this feeling... Despite it all if Rebecca called I’d be there on bended knee. Cause deep down I still hope that maybe she’d settle for....